Civil SuitDiscriminationMunicipal LiabilitySexual HarassmentVolunteers

Maryland EMT Alleges Sexual Harassment

An EMT with the Silver Spring Volunteer Fire Company has filed suit in federal court in Maryland alleging she has been sexually harassed and retaliated against. Susan Williams claims that a deputy chief harassed her over an extended period of time, and her attempts to make the harassment stop were not only ignored but prompted acts of retaliation by the department.

According to the complaint:

  • Deputy Chief John Thompson was Ms. Williams' supervisor and as such supervised her and gave her work related orders, which she was required to obey.
  • From late 2007 /early 2008 through his resignation, Deputy Chief Thompson would regularly make sexually suggestive comments to her.
  • During monthly SSFD meetings, and in the presence of other members, Deputy Chief Thompson would intimately sit next to Ms. Williams and position himself so he could suggestively rub his leg against her body.
  • In early February 2008, at a SSFD fundraising event, Deputy Chief Thompson sought out Ms. Williams, began to grope her and fondled her rear end.
  • In March 2008, when Ms. Williams picked up an accident report from Station 16, Deputy Chief Thompson informed her that he dressed up just for her and then told her that he could help her change her charge status and recommended the two of the take the ambulance out on a drive.
  • On or June 12, 2008, during a SSFD Board Meeting where other members were present, including Fire Chief Roger McGary, Deputy Chief Daniel Blankfeld and Lieutenant Christopher Saupto, Deputy Chief Thompson sat on Ms. Williams lap, bounced on her lap and proceeded to grind his rear end on her lap.
  • While he was grinding against Ms. Williams, Deputy Chief Thompson proceeded to tell the members in the room that "his seat" was on top of Ms. Williams' lap.

Williams complained to the internal affairs officer of the Montgomery County Fire Department. Following an investigation it was determined that Chief Thompson had sexually harassed Williams.

  • Upon information and belief, the Internal Affairs Investigator informed Fire Chief McGary of his findings and advised Fire Chief McGary to remove Deputy Chief Thompson.
  • Fire Chief McGary was offended that a Montgomery County representative was telling him what he should do and did not remove Deputy Chief Thompson or take any action against Deputy Chief Thompson to address or remedy him sexually harassing Ms. Williams.
  • Shortly after complaining, Fire Chief McGary verbally criticized Ms. Williams and, in reference to her complaints, told her that she "should have kept this in-house."
  • The investigation and its findings did not deter Deputy Chief Thompson from continuing to harass Ms. Williams. The harassment included further sexual comments and, with his vehicle, blocking her in her parking spot.
  • On or around early January 2010, during a SSFD meeting where approximately 40 members were present, Deputy Chief Thompson stood up, pointed his finger at Ms. Williams and shouted in front of the entire assembly "Susan, isn't it true you have a lawsuit against Silver Spring?"
  • Even after he was told to sit down by his supervisors, Deputy Chief Thompson insisted that he "was speaking to Susan" and continued to belittle Ms. Williams and shout "Susan, don't you have a lawsuit against the Department?"

Williams claims in addition to the harassment and retaliation, she was denied training opportunities and assignments, and threatened with discipline.  She filed a timely complaint with the EEOC who concluded that she was the victim of sexual harassment. When conciliation efforts between Williams and the department failed, she filed suit in US District Court.

The suit was filed yesterday, with four counts:

  • Count 1 – quid pro quo sexual harassment
  • Count 2 – retaliation
  • Count 3 – hostile work environment sexual harassment
  • Count 4 – sex discrimination

The complaint seeks unnamed compensatory damages and $3 million in punitive damages.

Here is a copy of the complaint: Williams v Silver Spring

Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 50 years of fire service experience and 40 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. Besides his law degree, he has a MS in Forensic Psychology. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014, 4th ed. 2022) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.

Related Articles

9 Comments

  1. What troubles me the most is not the actions of the Deputy Chief, after all there is always going to be at least one Neanderthal in any sufficiently large group. What really bugs me is all the other people that didn't have the balls to stand up and say "That's not right." and stop it at the get go. 

  2. Jim is absolutely correct. For some reason, today's fire officers seem to think that all those sexual harrassment courses were "how-to" classes. This post and the one preceeding both show command officers as leaders who have no clue as to what they're supposed to be doing.

    I've said it before, and I'll say it again… the first classes in police, fire OR EMS academies have to be "Keeping It Your Pants 101" and "Shut Your G*ddamned Mouth, You MORON 101."

    Than and only then will we be able to turn our attention the thingslike "Putting the Wet Stuff on the Red Stuff – Advanced Placement" and "Operations Seminar: What's This Ladder Thing For?"

  3. 2nd multi-million dollar sexual harassment suit in Maryland involving a volunteer department this week. (the other being Berlin). Its a sad state of affairs when Maryland, which has a model of intrastate trauma systems for the country is in the headlines for people acting morel ike cavemen and homophobic morons then how its saving lives with its combined statewide system.  (I know the articles arent involving the state directly obviously but both situations reflect badly as a whole on the mentality of a state which is considered rather progressive and liberal by most)

  4. As a lieutenant i cant believe her officers did nothing to stop the harassment and insist reprecussions be handed out. This obviously wasnt an incident or two where things were a simple misunderstanding because someone was being immature and then stopped once attention was brought to it. I wouldnt allow a rookie to get away with such assinine behavior. Im all for having a lighthearted fun atmosphere and picking at each other in good fun for comraderie. This however is grossly not that at all. Its even more sad that the chief not only ignored the situation but for all intents allowed this behavior to continue and then belittled a subordinate because he did not take appropriate action.

    Yes, that states renowned trauma system should also be highlighted. However, it is important for such cases to also be brought to light. Not only is it wrong to treat another person in this way. It is unprofessional. I for one dpmt want us to carry the burden of a reputation that police officers have to carry . Because like us, most of them are hardworking, good people, serving our community. Yet necause they have boneheads making bad choices covered by the media they have to deal with an overall negative reputation.

    You put on that uniform, especially if you have bugles on your collar; you should conduct yourself in a manner that brings only pride upon our profession and fellow brothers and sisters. We all make mistakes, and that is okay. However, there are lines that are not okay to cross. Doing so blatantly is pathetic.

  5. While i understand this is serious and i hope the woman wins, i must put some things out in the open.  Being a career firefighter for The county and assigned to Silver Spring for 10yrs now, the only person in this article that i know is Chief McGary.  That being said, they have hundreds of volunteers on paper, about 4 that ride the rigs and a few others that have take home vehicles and buggys that are never used on incidents, they get used for personal errands, a daily work vehicle and who knows what else.  I was recently told they have 100sets of brand new gear locked up and its six years old!!  This social club should not be sexually abusing anyone but at the same time, it should'nt be broadcast across fire dept websites,  broadcast it  across VFW or Elk Lodge sites.

  6. Truth be told

    I am not sure I understand your point. When you say "it shouldn't be broadcast across fire dept websites" are you saying that I should not be discussing her allegations… or that she should not be complaing to the EEOC and federal courts?

    Also – what is up with the simultaneous defense and slamming of the volunteers at Silver Spring?

  7. As someone who also works in the county as a career firefighter I say that broadcasting this is exactly what should be done.  People need to learn that this type of behavior is unacceptable and that there are consequences when they act in this manner; broadcasting the message far and wide is the only way anyone learns anything and the only way any behaviour modification will come.

    Trying to sweep this type of dirt under the rug just begets more dirt.

  8. Dallas, I agree. As a long time volunteer in the county, and a neighboring department, I know all the individuals being accused or listed as witnesses. Sadly, I'm not surprised about most of them. When I joined in the 80's this kind of thing was "acceptable". Its time our departments got with reality, it never was acceptable, and now its just plain illegal. The old boy's club days needed to end 20 years ago.

Back to top button